Earlier this week Apple was effectively given an overdue tax bill from the European Union’s anti-trust commission for around $15 billion. Apple can certainly pay one $15 billion bill. However, this would also eliminate its related tax breaks from Ireland, which protected Apple profits across the EU and that will have a lasting, painful impact on its financial performance.
Why I think Apple is screwed is that this massive tax is very material to every Irish citizen—about $3,000 per person—making it very likely that those that support Apple and are currently fighting the EU will be politically motivated to change sides or lose their elected jobs. For instance, assuming you are in the US, if you were told that finding against Apple would reduce our own personal Tax bill by $3,000, would you support Apple or—like most—figure Apple kind of owes you the money because it made so much off you over the last few years (Apple does have something like $500 billion in reserves).
Ireland has for some time been one of the biggest EU tax havens, and it has paid dividends for the country which has largely emerged from the decades-old bank collapse. In fact, Ireland is healthier than when it entered it—suggesting the smart play would be to leave Apple, and a system that is largely working, alone. However, that would be strategic thinking and something governments are generally not known for. As a result, I think Apple, and a lot of other companies that have been using Ireland as a tax haven, are screwed.
I’ve covered the European Commission on prior cases. They have full authority to fine, but little else and its operations are funded by the fines. It is rarely overturned and—from a political standpoint—pounding on US companies to get funds EU countries desperately need will be very popular.
Let’s talk about other reasons not only Apple is screwed but other companies both in Europe and the US may be as well.
Apple Is Theoretically In The Right
Apple has one of the strongest legal teams on the planet and, as noted, it is hardly alone in this practice of using Ireland as a tax haven. And it worked for Ireland because even at this low tax rate Apple leads other companies in Ireland in terms of the amount of taxes it has already paid. If the favorable tax rate wasn’t in place, Apple likely wouldn’t be in Ireland and rather than getting a very small percentage of something Ireland would get a huge percentage of nothing. Apple exploited what appears to be a solid loophole only to have it slammed shut by the European Commission.
But the issue for Apple is that Ireland likely never should have had the power to bind all of the EU anymore than Michigan can set tax policy for the entire United States. So, while Apple played according to the rules, and from Ireland’s standpoint as well as Apple’s this is a great deal—Ireland isn’t the EU and the deal screws other EU countries. Pretty badly, actually. From a standpoint of competition it gives Apple a significant advantage against theoretical competitors based anywhere that don’t have this massive tax advantage, giving the EU Commission a very strong argument that Apple has an unfair advantage and driving the issue into its jurisdiction.
The EU Commission is known for being tenacious. Also, as I noted, its power is in taxes and when going against Microsoft some years ago it used this power to tax Microsoft billions and this got Microsoft—which had been incredibly resilient to efforts to change its behavior up till then—to change. This showcases that even against some of the most powerful companies in the world (the European Commission is also causing Google some issues now) it seems to prevail.
Apple’s ability to fight this lies largely with its support from the Irish government, but Ireland is hardly the most powerful EU country. That would be Germany, and Germany isn’t a fan of things like loopholes—particularly if they give US companies an advantage over German firms. In addition, the amount of money being tossed around is massive and, as I noted above, material to every Irish citizen. If we also add the billions that may be taken from other firms that are using this loophole, the monetary incentive for Irish citizens to vote out the folks that support Apple is massive.
Finally, this appears to have been triggered by a plan for British companies which will be hurt when Britain exits from the EU to go to Ireland and use the Apple benefits to end up ahead. Germany, in particular, would be massively against this and it can take a shot at Apple and keep that from happening without looking like it’s piling on Britain.
As a result, I don’t see a path out of this for Apple. The loophole was unfair to the EU and EU companies. The money makes Apple’s position almost impossible to support by even Irish politicians long term. The need to block British companies from doing the same thing is extreme.
I think Apple is screwed—not only for the initial bill, but for tax treatment going forward. This may be the tip of the iceberg as the US has been unhappy with this tax treatment as well, and there are a ton of other companies that will likely be hit that don’t have Apple’s mammoth reserves.
- Cisco: Replacing AC with DC and PoE for Everything - December 7, 2022
- ARM, FTX, Meta and Twitter: Why the List of Failing Tech Darlings Is Increasing - November 28, 2022
- How to Beat Apple (And Why Would You Want To?) - November 22, 2022